
Notice anything ... irregular about this post? This Substack is now Presumption of Irregularity, the blog half of a relaunch. Every Ballot Counts is becoming the research site at everyballotcounts.io, and this is where my opinions live. Same subscription, same person, same receipts. There's a proper announcement post (and socials) coming later today.
Friday afternoon, the FAA stopped every departing flight in the country for almost five hours.1 By Saturday morning the Transportation Secretary had a culprit, and it wasn't China, or Iran, or anybody's hackers. "It wasn't a foreign actor," he said. It was a crew from L3Harris, the FAA's own contractor, doing upgrade work on the FAA's own network.2 The FAA's word for it is an "equipment issue" during a telecommunications network upgrade.3
So the government's contractor broke the government's network while doing the government's upgrade ... and Friday night, two cabinet secretaries stood outside the White House and gave the president a standing ovation for getting us through it.
The briefing, lightly annotated
Homeland Security Secretary Markwayne Mullin opened with this:4
"This is what the leadership of President Trump looks like by the organization and the team he's put together."
![Comment [A1]: Honestly? Yes. It is. Comment [A1]: Honestly? Yes. It is.](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!FOhU!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F04641b52-d922-4858-b467-f0b47958dc89_2912x580.png)
Honestly? Yes. It is. That's the whole post, thanks for reading.
(Fine, there's more.) Mullin also said "I just can't speak enough about President Trump's leadership" and "President Trump immediately had people in his office."5 Duffy wasn't about to be out-thanked: "Markwayne and I were in The Oval with him, which, by the way, I appreciate his leadership." Then "This is the greatest country, by the way, with the greatest president," and "President Trump is a builder; he's going to build this network." And my personal favorite: "Now, I have already replaced some of those switches with President Trump."6 I would pay actual money to see the president with a crimping tool.
Meanwhile, the builder spent part of the ground stop meeting with Jon Voight about a federal film tax credit.7 By Saturday morning he still hadn't posted about the outage on Truth Social, though he did tell Fox's Peter Doocy by phone that it didn't seem like a cyberattack or AI and was, in Doocy's words, "a bunch of old broken stuff in the infrastructure that the FAA relies on to keep planes in the sky."8
Not everybody was grounded
Duffy explained who got to fly anyway: "we were going to allow those lifesaving movements to still occur, as well as with law enforcement as well."9
Lifesaving flights, obviously. But "law enforcement" is a pretty big bucket when the department running this briefing also runs ICE Air. Did removal flights keep going while everyone else sat on the tarmac? I don't know yet, and I haven't seen anyone report it either way ... but the flight trackers will, and I'll be reading.
A rocket also got to fly. SpaceX's Starship launch window opened at 5:45 pm ET on Friday,10 right in the middle of the national ground stop, and it launched. The FAA is the agency that licenses those launches and clears the sky for them. A few hours later, Hawaii's transportation department posted: "All west coast flights have been halted due to debris from SpaceX launch."11 (Rocket airspace is its own process, so this may be nothing. It's still a heck of a Friday for the FAA.)
About that $50 billion
This is the part where I put my coffee down.
On Thursday (the day before anything broke), budget director Russ Vought and Duffy sent appropriators a letter asking for $30.1 billion more for aviation and calling the money Congress already gave them a "down-payment."12 (Hi, Russ.) That's on top of the $12.5 billion for air traffic control that Congress put in last year's reconciliation bill, which is available through September 2029.13
On Friday, the system broke, and by Friday night the number had grown: "the president has asked for $30 billion. I want $50 billion."14 Mullin added, "The president has declared this a national emergency, and now we have to have Congress act and fund it," and DHS put out a release calling it "a national security risk because our air traffic control system is outdated and it hasn't been a priority from Congress."15
As of Saturday afternoon there's no proclamation, no executive order and nothing in the Federal Register.16 So we have a "national emergency" that exists because two secretaries said so at a podium, and it's being used to add $20 billion to a request that went out the day before.
It also happened in Stephen Miller's first week as White House chief of staff.17 Declare an emergency out loud, skip the paperwork and dare Congress to say no to the money ... that's a playbook he knows well, and I don't think the timing is a coincidence. (That last bit is my opinion, not a fact.)
The best analogy I've got: on Thursday I write my landlord asking for a new kitchen. On Friday, the electrician I hired trips the breaker for the whole building while working on my kitchen. Friday night I'm in the lobby telling the neighbors it's a national emergency, thanking myself for my leadership, and informing the landlord that the kitchen now costs $50 billion. (The landlord is you, by the way.)
"Someone" and "one"
Mullin said two more things worth sitting with: "We need someone to come in and build the whole system," and "We need one complete system."18
Someone, singular, and one system. That's not how you talk about a competition. And emergencies are exactly how you skip one: the federal rules let an agency go to a single source when there's "unusual and compelling urgency."19 (The FAA has its own buying rules, so I'm still checking how they handle this.)
The FAA also already has a someone. Peraton is the prime integrator on the air traffic control rebuild, and back in August Politico reported the FAA was frustrated with it and considering "scaling back Peraton's role." AT&T has since taken over the lead on the new telecom network.20 And now Duffy says of L3Harris, "We're going to hold people accountable."21 So whose work gets taken away, and who's next in line for it?
Meanwhile, the AI tool (and the family tree)
There's one more contractor in this story. In June, Duffy announced that a startup called Air Space Intelligence would build the FAA's new AI air traffic management system, SMART, on a contract worth up to $875.9 million, and Politico later reported the FAA was working on buying an ownership stake in the company.22
According to Raw Story, citing FEC records, Air Space Intelligence gave $12,500 in March to the congressional campaign of Michael Alfonso,23 the Wisconsin Republican who just won his race and who also happens to be Duffy's son-in-law.24 (I haven't pulled the FEC filing myself yet, and I want to see exactly who gave what, so treat the number as reported for now.)
The company says the ground stop was "not based on or a result of the SMART system,"25 and I have nothing that says otherwise. But "the old stuff broke, so fund the new stuff" is a little harder to take at face value when the new stuff is being built by a company that donates to the Secretary's family.
Where's DHS in all this?
The FAA is part of the Transportation Department, so why was the Homeland Security Secretary leading the briefing? Mullin answered that himself: "This is why we were stood up, to have a continuity of government to bring all the resources together in an emergency like this." He said the Department of War, CISA and the NSA were all working on it.26
That's row 3 on our tripwire board. A system fails, someone says "national emergency," someone else says they're "not ruling out" a cyberattack, and DoD, NSA and the FBI are already in the room. Friday's version was about airplanes and money. An election-night version would be about pollbooks, results websites and ballots ... and now we've watched them run the script once, in public.
My tinfoil-hat paragraph (clearly labeled)
This is pure speculation, I have zero evidence for it, and I'm only writing it down because it's been rattling around my head all morning. If a contractor ever warned that this kind of work could take the network down, and somebody let it go ahead anyway because a meltdown makes a better pitch to Congress than a memo, that would be a breach of the oath of office. I want to be really clear that I have no reason to believe that happened.
What I do know is that the letter asking for the money went out the day before.27 What would settle it either way is the L3Harris work order and its risk notes, whether the FAA signed off on the maintenance window, and the FAA's own after-action report. If you have any of those, you know where to find me.
Coming up next
Next up is the update I promised on hacking government data with government data to claim a hack of ... government data. The contractors-and-Project-2025 piece I had planned for part 3 is on the back burner while I go watch the Great American Road Trip at 100x speed and hope something of value turns up before my eyeballs self-destruct. But hey, it makes a nice break from the Stephen Miller archives.
— Amanda
![Sources: D, R, [P] Sources: D, R, [P]](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9vbk!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F3c8a6d8e-aae2-44d5-82cb-4c3ed3242dbb_2912x240.png)
D: Document. The official record says it: a transcript, release, filing, order, contract or notice. Here that means things like the briefing transcript and the DHS release.
R: Reporting. Published journalism says it, and the endnote links the story, like Roll Call on the Vought-Duffy letter or Raw Story on the AI contractor.
The full citation and link for every numbered claim is in the endnotes at the bottom.
[P] Presumed.
Everything above without a number is me. That includes the standing ovation, the landlord, the crimping tool, the Miller timing and the entire tinfoil-hat paragraph. The numbered parts are what the government and the press actually said; the rest is what a contracts lawyer does with a Friday night and a transcript.
Every Ballot Counts is the research; Presumption of Irregularity is the opinion. Same person, same receipts. Not legal advice. My views are my own and not those of my employer.

D. Duffy at the Nov 13 briefing: the stop ran from 3:36 to 8:15 pm ET. Transcript
R. New York Times live updates, Nov 14; Politico, "Duffy points finger at FAA contractor for nationwide ground stop," Nov 14; Bloomberg, "Duffy Probing Possible L3Harris 'Incompetence' in FAA Meltdown," Nov 14.
R. NPR, "FAA blames Friday's ground stop on 'equipment issue' during telecoms network upgrade," Nov 14.
D. Mullin, Nov 13 briefing. Transcript
D. Mullin, Nov 13 briefing. Transcript
D. Duffy, Nov 13 briefing. Transcript
R. Variety, "Amid Flight Halt, Trump Meets With Jon Voight to Talk U.S. Film Incentive," Nov 13.
R. The Independent, Nov 14, quoting Doocy on The Ingraham Angle.
D. Duffy, Nov 13 briefing. Transcript
R. Spaceflight Now (75-minute window opening 5:45 pm ET); CNBC, "SpaceX launches Starship in key test flight," Nov 13.
R. Hawaii News Now, Nov 14, quoting the Hawaii Department of Transportation.
D. Duffy, Nov 13 briefing. Transcript
D. Mullin, Nov 13 briefing, and the DHS release, Nov 13.
D. Federal Register search for "national emergency," published Nov 13 or later (zero results); White House presidential actions page (latest item Nov 12). Checked Nov 14, 12:45 pm ET.
D. Mullin, Nov 13 briefing. Transcript
D. FAR 6.302-2.
R. AvWeb, Aug 20, citing Politico, Aug 19; Nextgov, Aug 14 (AT&T as lead on the telecom replacement).
R. New York Times live updates, Nov 14; Politico, "Duffy points finger at FAA contractor for nationwide ground stop," Nov 14; Bloomberg, "Duffy Probing Possible L3Harris 'Incompetence' in FAA Meltdown," Nov 14.
D. Mullin, Nov 13 briefing, and the DHS release, Nov 13.


