
Part two of "What's the BS, Ru$$?" Part one was the legal setup: how federal cyber law lets the government act on a suspicion.1 This one is about how words travel ... and why I read everything twice.
I started this project because of one phrase. In September, the Defense Secretary told the Pentagon's intelligence agencies "to mobilize every authorized asset, capability, and partnership under your command to defend our election infrastructure."2 I'm a contracts lawyer. When a document says "every," I go find out what "every" can reach.
That's the habit behind what we call the phrase trail. Every document we pull (a filing, a press release, a think-tank paper, a letter) gets checked against a word list and against everything we've already read. Most days it turns up nothing. This week it turned up a federal lawsuit whose opening lines were written by the Department of Homeland Security. And when I followed one of those lines back, it led to a letter Russ Vought signed in 2022.
The lawsuit
On Oct. 27, the Potter County Republican Party (Amarillo) and its chairman, Daniel Rogers, sued the county's elections administrator in federal court and asked to make her the stand-in for every county election official in Texas.3 They want every Texas county to hand count the federal races before certification. They drew Judge Matthew Kacsmaryk. Their lead lawyer, Jared Woodfill, is a former Harris County GOP chair who has spent years filing election suits, including the 2020 bid to throw out 127,000 drive-through votes in Houston.4
Late Friday night they amended it. The new version asks that results be "confirmed, or corrected to match the hand count where they differ," and that the final count rest on "all lawful paper ballots from all lawful Texas citizens."5
Here's how it opens:
"Election security is national security. Electronic voting systems have one job—to accurately count the votes on ballots."6
No quotation marks. In a complaint, that means the plaintiffs are saying it themselves.
The receipts
Here's DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin's Aug. 24 letter to the White House's Government Transparency Task Force, next to the amended complaint:78

![Comment [A1]: Plagiarism is a strong word. Let's go with 'efficient.' Comment [A1]: Plagiarism is a strong word. Let's go with 'efficient.'](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!LFyB!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F757afd9d-e204-4c88-ac91-8729b477c899_2912x880.png)
To be fair, the complaint footnotes the letter in places and quotes Mullin by name further down. But I ran the whole thing. Counting only runs of eight or more words in a row, the amended complaint reproduces 374 of the letter's 758 words, including the entire China-parts paragraph and the letter's footnote links.9
The letter's own file has a story too. The copy Just the News posted still has its document properties: author "Disalvo, Karen," created in Word at 4:44 p.m. on Aug. 24.10 Karen DiSalvo is a senior adviser in DHS's policy office who co-founded the Election Research Institute with Heather Honey, now DHS's deputy assistant secretary for election integrity. Democracy Docket caught that first, back in August.11 And in Georgia, the same package went from the State Election Board's executive director back to DHS and DOJ as a reason to act, weeks before Texas.1213
So a federal court is being asked to override machine counts across all of Texas, and the core argument is a cabinet secretary's letter, retyped as a county party's own allegations.
That's the copy/paste. Now the flattery.
"Trust, but verify"
That third row bugged me. "Trust but verify" is an old Reagan line, so on its own it means nothing. But DHS put it in a grant condition, and grant conditions don't write themselves. So I ran it back through everything we have.
On Aug. 10, 2022, Russ Vought went on Tucker Carlson and said there was "systemic voter fraud" in North Carolina "at the State Board of Election level and the DMV." The state board called it false.14 Nine days later, Vought sent the board an open letter.15 (This was Biden's second year. Vought had run OMB, the office that oversees every federal agency's budget, until January 2021.16) Here's what he asked for:
"the old adage 'trust, but verify' most certainly applies"
had the state run "a statewide de-duping of its voter rolls utilizing all available federal and state databases"?
"Were there any attempts to utilize any additional federal and state databases that you were subsequently denied access to?"
SAVE, the federal citizenship check, was too narrow: it "will only return results" on people USCIS is "formally aware of"
and what about people "who do not show up in any of the databases"?
Read that list again with 2026 eyes. He's not asking North Carolina to fix a DMV form. He's asking for every voter to be checked against every database the government has, with nobody denied access, and with a citizenship check that can see people it can't see yet.
I searched our whole archive and the web for that exact phrase, "all available federal and state databases." It turns up in one place: Russ's letter.
The ladder
Here's what happened to each item on Russ's list. Every rung has a document behind it.
2023: the plan writes it down. The DHS chapter of Project 2025's Mandate for Leadership (Russ wrote the chapter on the Executive Office of the President) says states and cities applying for DHS grants should commit to "total information-sharing" with federal law and immigration enforcement, "includ[ing] access to department of motor vehicles and voter registration databases." Same chapter: on election security, CISA should help states with cyber hygiene "but nothing more." And DHS's Privacy Office should be folded under a political appointee.17
March 2025: the order. Executive Order 14248 tells DHS, "in coordination with the DOGE Administrator," to "review each State's publicly available voter registration list and available records" against federal immigration databases, "including through subpoena where necessary."18
May 2025: SAVE gets the upgrade Russ asked for. DHS and SSA plugged Social Security records into SAVE, so it could check U.S.-born citizens, not just people with immigration files. They launched it with no public privacy notice. DHS's own privacy reviews later found it "not in compliance" with the Privacy Act.19 The man running USCIS, the agency that runs SAVE, is Joseph Edlow, a visiting fellow at Russ's Center for Renewing America right before he took the job.20
2025-26: every state gets the letter. The Justice Department demanded full, unredacted voter rolls from the states. It sued 30 states and D.C. when they said no, and as of last week it had lost 28 of those cases.21 At least 18 states handed theirs over, and a federal judge found DOJ shared them with ICE's investigative arm to "enrich" them.22 By the summer, DHS said 25 states had run 68 million voter records through SAVE.23 Then came the subpoenas: more than 100 to election officials in at least a dozen states, many under grand-jury authority.24
2026: where the data goes. ICE's own records describe an "Election Integrity Investigations" pipeline of "voter roll acquisition, data enrichment, intelligence analysis, lead development, field validation." A July 6 report says six states' rolls "have been enriched by the iLab and are pending Palantir entry into ELITE," ICE's enforcement system.25 (Palantir has denied integrating voter data.26) That's not checking a list. That's building a file on every voter.
Remember the states Trump's side fought over after 2020? Georgia, Pennsylvania, Michigan and Nevada all show up in this year's pressure: Georgia's whole roll went through SAVE and its data is on ICE's "enriched" list; Pennsylvania and Nevada got DHS "preliminary review" letters; Michigan fought DOJ for its roll and won on appeal; Nevada's election chief got seven grand-jury subpoenas.27
July 2026: the money. Russ's plan said to tie DHS grants to state data. In July, FEMA's Homeland Security Grant Program (counterterrorism money) carried election conditions: hold back 20% unless a state used SAVE, moved off QR-code ballots and ran manual audits.28 That's where Mullin's "trust but verify" line comes from. A federal judge vacated those conditions on Sept. 28.29 The same day, Georgia's State Election Board adopted the resolution that sent the package back to DHS and DOJ.30 Six weeks later, the same sentences turned up in a Texas courtroom.31
This isn't the first time they've reached for the grant money, either. A judge struck DHS's 2025 requirement that FEMA grant recipients, including for disaster and emergency-preparedness money, "honor requests for cooperation" with immigration agents, calling it "both arbitrary and capricious and unconstitutional."32 Another judge, a Trump appointee, blocked DHS from moving homeland-security money away from states that wouldn't cooperate: "unconscionable and, at least here, unlawful."33
The courts already said it
I'd been calling this a privacy problem. Two federal rulings call it a Privacy Act violation.
In June, Judge Sparkle Sooknanan vacated the souped-up SAVE and found that the government "knowingly trampled on the privacy rights of American citizens," having "haphazardly combined and repurposed the private information of millions of Americans, including citizenship data that they knew to be unreliable."34 In October, the same judge vacated DOJ's voter-list policy and held it violated the Privacy Act too.35 DOJ is appealing.
The people
Same shop, every time:
Russ Vought founded the Center for Renewing America and now runs OMB again.36
Stephen Miller founded America First Legal, which CPI says it helped launch. Last Monday, Nov. 9, he became White House chief of staff. When a government hunt for rigged voting machines came up empty, Reuters reported that Miller "pushed to expand the probe and involve the FBI."37
Mark Meadows was Trump's chief of staff the last time a Trump term was ending. He went straight to the Conservative Partnership Institute, which says he "helped incubate and launch" the Center for Renewing America, America First Legal and CPI's Election Integrity Initiative.38 Cleta Mitchell's Election Integrity Network is a CPI project, and ProPublica reported Friday that five sources say Georgia's election-board director worked closely with its members.39
Joseph Edlow, a fellow at Russ's center, runs the agency that runs SAVE.40
To be clear: I haven't found Russ's name, or CPI's, on the Potter County case. The words in the complaint come from DHS's letter. What I found is that the idea behind the letter (check everyone, against everything, and tie the money to it) was Russ's ask in 2022, written into the 2023 plan, and built in 2025 and 2026 by people from his network. [P]
So what's the big surprise?
On Oct. 6, Trump said: "We have some big surprises coming up in a few weeks, right Russ?"41 On Nov. 1, Reuters reported that the White House has been planning since April for a Democratic Congress, and that Vought is looking for grant-rule changes that give political appointees more control.42
I don't know what the surprise is. Here's what worries me. [P] A file on every voter, built from every database, run through tools like Palantir's, is the most powerful thing you could hand to someone who wants to decide whose vote counts. You can challenge a voter with it. You can purge one. You can build a "real voter" list and dare a court to stop you before Jan. 3. And you can use it for anything else, against anyone. That's the recipe for a dictatorship. Voters just delivered an actual mandate that they don't like any of this, and I expect the people who built it to do whatever they can between now and Jan. 3 to hold on.
What's next
Monday: Potter County runs its regular post-election hand-count audit.43
Tuesday: the county's reply is due, and the judge said no extensions.44 It's also the last day Texas counties can canvass.45
Still not filed: a motion for a preliminary injunction. The judge told them to file one by Nov. 6. They asked for more time and haven't filed since.4647
The county's own lawyer calls the suit "statewide intervention into the process of certifying election results based on no more than theoretical possibility."48
That's why we read everything twice. Sentences don't stay where you leave them. They get lifted, reused, retyped and refiled, and every time they pick up a little more authority. Follow them back far enough and you find out who wanted them there first.
Hi again, Russ.
— Amanda
![Sources: D, R, [P] Sources: D, R, [P]](https://substackcdn.com/image/fetch/$s_!9vbk!,w_1456,c_limit,f_auto,q_auto:good,fl_progressive:steep/https%3A%2F%2Fsubstack-post-media.s3.amazonaws.com%2Fpublic%2Fimages%2F3c8a6d8e-aae2-44d5-82cb-4c3ed3242dbb_2912x240.png)
D: Document. The official record says it: a filing, a letter, an order, a court opinion, a document's own properties. Here that means things like the Potter County complaints, Mullin's letter, Russ's 2022 letter and two federal court opinions.
R: Reporting. Published journalism says it, and the endnote links the story, like ProPublica on Georgia or Reuters on the subpoenas.
The full citation and link for every numbered claim is in the endnotes at the bottom.
[P] Presumed.
Everything above without a number is me connecting documents that each stand on their own: the ladder from Russ's letter to the 2026 build, and what I think a file on every voter could be used for. If anyone named here wants to tell me it's all a coincidence, my inbox is open, and I'll print the reply. (Spoiler: it's still 374 words.)
Every Ballot Counts is the research; Presumption of Irregularity is the opinion. Same person, same receipts. Not legal advice. My views are my own and not those of my employer.

The 7-day clock starts whenever they say it does, Part one of this series (Nov. 11). Presumption of Irregularity
D. Defense Secretary's memo on countering foreign threats to the 2026 elections (Sept. 22, 2026). PDF
D. Potter County Republican Party v. Benge, No. 2:26-cv-00215-Z (N.D. Tex.), ECF 1, Class Action Complaint (Oct. 27, 2026). PDF
R. Jared Woodfill, background and election suits. Wikipedia (citing AP, Nov. 3, 2020, on the rejected bid to throw out 127,000 Houston votes)
D. Same case, ECF 72, First Amended Class Action Complaint (Nov. 14, 2026), ¶¶1-6 and Prayer for Relief. PDF
D. Same case, ECF 72, First Amended Class Action Complaint (Nov. 14, 2026), ¶¶1-6 and Prayer for Relief. PDF
D. Letter from DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin to the White House Transparency Task Force (Aug. 24, 2026), posted by the White House. ZIP
D. Same case, ECF 72, First Amended Class Action Complaint (Nov. 14, 2026), ¶¶1-6 and Prayer for Relief. PDF
D. Our comparison of ECF 1 and ECF 72 against the Aug. 24 letter, counting runs of eight or more identical words (ECF 1: 354 words; ECF 72: 374). Method and files on the phrase trail.
D. The same letter as posted by Just the News; its document properties list the author as "Disalvo, Karen" and the creation time as Aug. 24, 2026, 4:44 p.m. ET. PDF
R. Democracy Docket, "Exclusive: Another election denial leader, hired by DHS, drafted letter threatening states over voting audits" (Aug. 28, 2026). Democracy Docket
R. ProPublica, on the Georgia State Election Board and the Election Integrity Network (Nov. 13, 2026). ProPublica
D. North Carolina State Board of Elections, "State Board Responds to False Information from Fox News Guest" (Aug. 13, 2022). NCSBE
D. Russ Vought, Citizens for Renewing America, open letter to NCSBE Executive Director Karen Brinson Bell (Aug. 19, 2022). Citizens for Renewing America
R. Russell Vought: OMB deputy and acting director (2018-2020) and director (July 2020-2021); founder, Center for Renewing America; OMB director again since 2025. Wikipedia · Ballotpedia
D. Heritage Foundation, Mandate for Leadership (2023), Chapter 5, Department of Homeland Security, pp. 137-138 (grants and "total information-sharing"), the CISA "but nothing more" passage, and p. 164 (Privacy Office). PDF
D. Executive Order 14248, "Preserving and Protecting the Integrity of American Elections," sec. 2(b)(iii), 90 Fed. Reg. 14005 (Mar. 28, 2025). Federal Register
D. League of Women Voters v. DHS, No. 25-cv-3501 (D.D.C.), memorandum opinion (June 22, 2026). PDF
D. Joseph Edlow's Senate Judiciary questionnaire lists a Center for Renewing America visiting fellowship (Nov. 2024 to Jan. 2025). PDF
R. The Daily Signal on a DHS memo: 25 states, 68 million records run through SAVE (July 24, 2026). Daily Signal
R. Reuters on DOJ and DHS subpoenas to election officials (Oct. 28, 2026). Reuters via KELO
D. ICE records released to Democracy Forward under FOIA (production 2026-ICLI-00100, Oct. 1, 2026): HSI "Election Integrity Investigations" (June 15, 2026) and HSI weekly report (July 6, 2026). Democracy Forward
D/R. DHS letters to Pennsylvania and Nevada, as described in DSCC v. Trump, No. 1:26-cv-3674 (D.D.C.), complaint ¶¶59-73 (allegations) PDF; United States v. Benson (6th Cir. June 24, 2026), per the Congressional Research Service CRS; Reuters on Nevada's seven subpoenas (Oct. 15, 2026) Reuters via Internazionale. Georgia: the ICE records and the Reuters subpoena story cited above.
R. Democracy Docket on Judge Amir Ali's ruling striking the HSGP election conditions (Sept. 28, 2026): FEMA had no "authority to extract unfunded reforms from states in exchange for grants." Democracy Docket · Brennan Center case page
R. Democracy Docket on Judge Amir Ali's ruling striking the HSGP election conditions (Sept. 28, 2026): FEMA had no "authority to extract unfunded reforms from states in exchange for grants." Democracy Docket · Brennan Center case page
D. Same case, ECF 72, First Amended Class Action Complaint (Nov. 14, 2026), ¶¶1-6 and Prayer for Relief. PDF
D. League of Women Voters v. DHS, No. 25-cv-3501 (D.D.C.), memorandum opinion (June 22, 2026). PDF
R. Russell Vought: OMB deputy and acting director (2018-2020) and director (July 2020-2021); founder, Center for Renewing America; OMB director again since 2025. Wikipedia · Ballotpedia
D/R. White House, "President Trump Names Stephen Miller as 33rd White House Chief of Staff" (Nov. 2026) White House; Documented on America First Legal and CPI Documented; Reuters, "Trump aides chase vote-rigging claims even after latest probe finds nothing" (Apr. 23, 2026) Reuters via MarketScreener
R. ProPublica, on the Georgia State Election Board and the Election Integrity Network (Nov. 13, 2026). ProPublica
D. Joseph Edlow's Senate Judiciary questionnaire lists a Center for Renewing America visiting fellowship (Nov. 2024 to Jan. 2025). PDF
R. Reuters via the Detroit News (Nov. 2, 2026). Detroit News
D. Same case, ECF 72, First Amended Class Action Complaint (Nov. 14, 2026), ¶¶1-6 and Prayer for Relief. PDF
D. ECF 58, Plaintiffs' Motion for Extension of Time (Nov. 6, 2026), citing Tex. Elec. Code 67.003. PDF
D. ECF 58, Plaintiffs' Motion for Extension of Time (Nov. 6, 2026), citing Tex. Elec. Code 67.003. PDF
D. Docket, as of Nov. 15, 2026. CourtListener


